The Rising Cost of Non-Compliance in Data Protection

Although high-profile breaches are on the rise and regulations are becoming ever more stringent, many organisations continue to underestimate the true cost of non-compliance. It is important that businesses understand the impact extends well beyond fines, damaging trust, eroding market confidence, and jeopardising long-term resilience.

Escalating Regulatory Action

The UK’s Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) has taken an increasingly assertive stance. In the first half of 2025 alone, the ICO imposed more than £150 million in fines, representing a 45% increase in penalty size and a 30% rise in enforcement actions compared with the previous year. Strikingly, small and medium enterprises accounted for around 40% of those penalties. This demonstrates that no organisation, regardless of size, is immune from scrutiny.

High-Profile UK Cyber Breach Cases

• 23andMe (2023–24 attack) – Cybercriminals used a credential-stuffing attack, exploiting reused passwords from other sites to access genetic and personal data of over 155,000 UK residents. The ICO fined the company £2.31 million, citing the lack of multi-factor authentication and poor incident detection.

• Advanced Computer Software Group – Fell victim to a ransomware attack that compromised data for nearly 80,000 individuals. The attackers exploited weak security controls, and the business was fined £3.07 million. Beyond the fine, the ransomware caused severe disruption to services, showing how operational downtime can often outweigh regulatory costs.

• DPP Law Ltd – A Merseyside-based law firm suffered a cyber-attack that exposed client data. Criminals exploited unpatched software vulnerabilities, highlighting the risks of outdated IT infrastructure. The ICO fined the firm £60,000, a stark warning that even smaller organisations are not beyond the reach of cybercriminals.

• Sellafield Ltd – Though no confirmed theft occurred, cybercriminals had the potential to exploit critical vulnerabilities at Europe’s largest nuclear waste site. The fine of £332,500 illustrates how regulators now treat security gaps with the same seriousness as active breaches.

‍

Beyond the Financial Penalties

While the headlines focus on monetary fines, the wider costs of non-compliance are often more damaging:

1. Erosion of trust – customers and clients are far less forgiving when it comes to personal data mishandling. Trust, once lost, is difficult to regain.

2. Market value impact – Marks & Spencer, for example, saw a £700 million fall in market value following a cyber-attack, alongside a £300 million hit to profits. The long-tail financial impact dwarfs the scale of regulatory fines.

3. Operational disruption – ransomware and system downtime can paralyse entire operations, leading to lost productivity and customer dissatisfaction.

4. Legal exposure – affected individuals may pursue civil claims, and insurers increasingly challenge pay-outs where negligence is evident.

‍

Insights for Business Leaders

Data protection must be viewed not as a compliance burden, but as a business enabler. Organisations that take data security seriously can leverage it as a competitive advantage. Key steps include:

• Embedding security by design – ensuring new systems and services have robust protection built in from day one.

• Continuous monitoring – data protection is not a one-time exercise but an ongoing commitment to detect and mitigate threats in real time.

• Culture of accountability – leadership buy-in is essential. Employees at all levels must understand their role in safeguarding data.

• Third-party due diligence – supply chains are increasingly a weak link; auditing vendor security is now a critical component of compliance.

The message is clear: non-compliance is becoming more expensive not just in terms of regulatory fines, but in reputational harm and operational disruption. For UK businesses, data protection must shift from a reactive obligation to a proactive strategy. In a market where consumer trust is fragile and regulators are uncompromising, the cost of getting it wrong has never been higher. Is your data safe? Talk to our team of experts about your data protection strategy today. Synapse.com/contact

‍